Handcrafted in Parsonsburg · secure Square checkout

Shop Sugar Spell Treats.

Choose your favorites, see the exact total, select a date, and pay securely through Square—all in one clear ordering path.

1Build your cart
2Choose date & fulfillment
3Pay securely with Square

Choose a category

Shop Treats

Please place custom orders at least 2 weeks in advance whenever possible. Larger orders and events may require additional notice.

Everyday menu pricing shown. Custom, bulk & large orders are quoted separately. Pricing & Order Policy

Shop Bundle Deals ↓

Tray of Sugar Spell loaded chocolate chip cookies

FeaturedAvailable

Loaded Cookies

Loaded Chocolate Chip

A thick, generously loaded chocolate chip cookie.

From $5.50

Pack & price

Number of packs

FeaturedAvailable

Loaded Brownies

Caramel Apple Crumble Loaded Brownie

Caramel Apple Crumble loaded brownie.

From $6.00

Pack & price

Number of packs

Pink gift box filled with blue and white Sugar Spell cake pops on sticks

FeaturedAvailable

Cake Treats

Cake Pops

From $4.50

Pack & priceFlavor

Number of packs

Stick-free raspberry, magenta, and chocolate cake balls arranged in paper cups inside a pink gift box

FeaturedAvailable

Cake Treats

Cake Balls

From $4.00

Pack & priceFlavor

Number of packs

Save a little magic

Bundle Deals

Available

Bundle Deals

Treat Sampler

4 Loaded Cookies, 4 Loaded Brownies, and 6 Cake Pops. Choose your flavors. Save $4.

From $65.00

Pack & price

Choose 4 Cookies per boxLoaded Chocolate ChipS’moresLoaded Reese’s PiecesFrosted Animal CookieLoaded SnickersWhite Chocolate MacadamiaWhite Chocolate Macadamia Nut RaspberryLoaded OreoLoaded TwixFruity Pebbles StuffedApple Pie SnickerdoodleCinnamon RollFluffernutter Sandwich CookieRed Velvet Cookie Monster

0 / 4 selected

Choose 4 Brownies per boxCaramel Apple CrumbleS’moresReese’s OverloadPecan Pie

0 / 4 selected

Choose 6 Cake Pops per boxBirthday CakeOreoDouble ChocolateVanilla

0 / 6 selected

Number of packs

Available

Bundle Deals

Ultimate Sweet Box

12 Loaded Cookies, 6 Loaded Brownies, 6 Cake Pops, and 6 Dipped Oreos. Choose applicable flavors. Save $15.

From $130.00

Pack & price

Choose 12 Cookies per boxLoaded Chocolate ChipS’moresLoaded Reese’s PiecesFrosted Animal CookieLoaded SnickersWhite Chocolate MacadamiaWhite Chocolate Macadamia Nut RaspberryLoaded OreoLoaded TwixFruity Pebbles StuffedApple Pie SnickerdoodleCinnamon RollFluffernutter Sandwich CookieRed Velvet Cookie Monster

0 / 12 selected

Choose 6 Brownies per boxCaramel Apple CrumbleS’moresReese’s OverloadPecan Pie

0 / 6 selected

Choose 6 Cake Pops per boxBirthday CakeOreoDouble ChocolateVanilla

0 / 6 selected

Number of packs

Your standard order

Order Summary

0 packs

Your cart is ready for something sweet. Pick a pack from the menu to begin.

Pickup or delivery

PickupLocal pickup — Parsonsburg, Maryland

Date & contact

Needed dateChoose a date at least 3 days ahead.NameEmailPhone (optional)

Subtotal: $0.00
Pickup: $0.00
Tax (6%): $0.00
Total due on Square: $0.00

I reviewed my items, date, and fulfillment choice. I understand my order is confirmed after Sugar Spell accepts it and receives any required payment.

By submitting an order request, you understand that custom and large orders may be quoted separately from everyday menu pricing. Submitting a request does not guarantee availability or confirm an order. Your order is confirmed only after acceptance by Sugar Spell and receipt of any required deposit.

Pricing & Order Policy

Payment happens on Square’s secure hosted checkout. Your cart remains saved if you return without paying.

Need a custom design? Request a quote →

Shop Treats

Loaded Chocolate Chip

Caramel Apple Crumble Loaded Brownie

Cake Pops

Cake Balls

Bundle Deals

Cookie Lover Box

Treat Sampler

Ultimate Sweet Box